Exceptional Wide Scope as Anaphora to Quantificational Dependencies

نویسندگان

  • Adrian Brasoveanu
  • Donka F. Farkas
چکیده

The paper proposes a novel solution to the problem of exceptional scope (ES) of (in)definites, e.g. the widest and intermediate scope readings of the sentence Every student of mine read every poem that a famous Romanian poet wrote before World War II. We propose that ES readings are available when the sentence is interpreted as anaphoric to quantificational domains and quantificational dependencies introduced in the previous discourse. For example, the two every quantifiers and the indefinite in the example above may elaborate on the sets of individuals and the correlations between them introduced by a previous sentence like Every student chose a poet and read every poem written by him (for the intermediate scope reading) or a sentence like Every student chose a poet the same poet and read every poem written by him (for the widest scope reading). Our account, formulated within a compositional dynamic system couched in classical type logic, relies on two independently motivated assumptions: (a) the discourse context stores not only (sets of) individuals, but also quantificational dependencies between them, and (b) quantifier domains are always contextually restricted. Under this analysis, (in)definites are unambiguous and we do not resort to movement or special storage mechanisms, nor do we posit special choice-functional variables. 1 The Problem and the Basic Proposal The paper proposes a novel solution to the problem of exceptional scope (ES) of (in)definites (first noticed in [4]), a problem that is still open despite the many insightful attempts in the literature to solve it. The ES cases we focus on here are the widest and the intermediate scope readings of (1), given below in first order translations: 1. Every student of mine read every poem that a famous Romanian poet wrote before World War II. 2. Narrowest scope (NS) indefinite: ∀x(student.o.m(x) → ∀y(poem(y) ∧ ∃z(r.poet(z) ∧ write(z, y)) → read(x, y))) 3. a. Intermediate scope (IS) indefinite: ∀x(student.o.m(x) → ∃z(r.poet(z) ∧ ∀y(poem(y) ∧ write(z, y) → read(x, y)))) b. Context for the IS reading: Every student chose a poet and read every poem written by him. 4. a. Widest scope (WS) indefinite: ∃z(r.poet(z) ∧ ∀x(student.o.m(x) → ∀y(poem(y) ∧ write(z, y) → read(x, y)))) b. Context for the WS reading: Every student chose a poet – the same poet – and read every poem written by him. We start from the observation that the availability of the ES readings is crucially dependent on the discourse context relative to which sentence (1) is interpreted. In particular, the IS reading is available when (1) is interpreted in the context provided by (3b), which, in fact, forces an IS interpretation. Similarly, the WS reading is the only available one in the discourse context provided by (4b). Consequently, we propose that ES readings are available when sentence (1) is interpreted as anaphoric to quantificational domains and quantificational dependencies introduced in the previous discourse, i.e. when the two every determiners and the indefinite article in (1) further elaborate on the sets of individuals and the correlations between them introduced in (3b) and (4b) – as shown in (5), (6) and (7) below (the superscripts and subscripts indicate the antecedent-anaphor relations). The IS interpretation arises because of the presence in the input discourse context of a function pairing u-students and u-Romanian poets that rules out the possibility of

برای دانلود متن کامل این مقاله و بیش از 32 میلیون مقاله دیگر ابتدا ثبت نام کنید

ثبت نام

اگر عضو سایت هستید لطفا وارد حساب کاربری خود شوید

منابع مشابه

Structured Anaphora to Quantifier Domains A Unified Account of Quantificational and Modal Subordination and Exceptional Wide Scope

The paper proposes a novel analysis of quantificational subordination, e.g. Harvey courts a woman at every convention. {She is very pretty. vs. She always comes to the banquet with him.} (Karttunen 1976), in particular of the fact that the indefinite in the initial sentence can have wide or narrow scope, but the first discourse as a whole allows only for the wide scope reading, while the second...

متن کامل

Exceptional Scope as Discourse Reference to Quantificational Dependencies

The paper proposes a novel solution to the problem of exceptional scope (ES) of (in)definites, exemplified by the widest and intermediate scope readings of the sentence Every student of mine read every poem that a famous Romanian poet wrote. We propose that the ES readings have two sources: (i) discourse anaphora to particular sets of entities and quantificational dependencies between these ent...

متن کامل

Sentence-Internal Readings of Same / Different as Quantifier-Internal Anaphora

The main proposal is that distributive quantification temporarily makes available two discourse referents within its nuclear scope, the values of which are required by sentence-internal uses of same/different to be identical/distinct—much as their deictic uses require the values of two discourse referents to be identical/distinct. The formal account is independently motivated by quantificationa...

متن کامل

Structured Anaphora to Quantifier Domains: A Unified Account of Quantificational and Modal Subordination

The paper proposes an account of the contrast (noticed in [9]) between the interpretations of the following two discourses: Harvey courts a girl at every convention. {She is very pretty. vs. She always comes to the banquet with him.}. The initial sentence is ambiguous between two quantifier scopings, but the first discourse as a whole allows only for the wide-scope indefinite reading, while the...

متن کامل

Scope and Anaphoric Links in Dynamic Discourse Representation Theory

This paper analyzes anaphoric links in conditional and quantificational structures in which more than one operator occurs. To this end, we adopt the indexing system and the basic principles of Dynamic Discourse Representation Theory proposed by Chung (2008a, 2008b, 2009) and extend them to the structures in question. We also propose that a restrictor discourse representation structure of a quan...

متن کامل

ذخیره در منابع من


  با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید

برای دانلود متن کامل این مقاله و بیش از 32 میلیون مقاله دیگر ابتدا ثبت نام کنید

ثبت نام

اگر عضو سایت هستید لطفا وارد حساب کاربری خود شوید

عنوان ژورنال:

دوره   شماره 

صفحات  -

تاریخ انتشار 2007